Home / Guides / Social media freelancer vs agency vs doing it yourself: which is right?

Social media guide

Social media freelancer vs agency vs doing it yourself: which is right?

There's no single right answer, but there is a right answer for your budget, your time and how important social media is to your sales.

By Cornelius Oni · Updated 2026-11-16

The short answer: do it yourself if you have time and almost no budget; hire a freelancer or small team if you want it done properly for a few hundred pounds a month; choose an agency when you need several platforms, video production and ads; and hire in-house only when social media is a main sales channel and there's a full-time job's worth of work.

The options compared

OptionTypical UK costTypical US costBest for
Do it yourselfYour time, plus tools from free to about £30 a monthYour time, plus toolsVery early businesses with time to spare
Freelancer or small team£250 to £1,200 a month$750 to $1,500 a month for 1 to 2 platformsMost local and small businesses
Agency£800 to £5,000+ a month$2,000 to $5,000 a month for small business programsSeveral platforms, video, ads and campaigns
In-house hireAbout £2,400 to £3,400 a month in employer costsA full salary plus benefitsBusinesses where social is a main sales channel

UK ranges are from Whito and Bare Creative; US ranges are from Ordinal, citing Fresh Content Society for agency programs. All are planning ranges, not quotes.

Doing it yourself

Pros: free, and nobody knows your business better than you. Cons: it takes hours every week, it's the first thing dropped when you're busy, and a quiet feed can look like a closed business. Make it work: pick one platform, post three times a week, batch your content once a week, and use a simple weekly plan.

Freelancer or small team

Pros: affordable, personal, and you talk to the person doing the work. Cons: one person can get ill or go on holiday, and quality varies a lot. Make it work: check their portfolio and reviews, ask who covers when they're away, and make sure you approve a monthly plan. A small team of two or three gives you the personal service with more cover.

Agency

Pros: a full team of strategists, designers, video editors and ads specialists. Cons: it costs more, there are often 6 to 12-month contracts, and small clients can get passed to junior staff. Make it work: ask exactly who will run your account and what's delivered each month.

In-house hire

Pros: someone who lives and breathes your brand and can film on site every day. Cons: the most expensive option once you add National Insurance, pension, tools and holiday cover, and one person rarely has every skill. Make it work: hire when there's clearly more than a freelancer's worth of work.

How to decide in two minutes

  1. Under £250 a month? Do it yourself, or hire help for a one-off set-up and content plan.
  2. £250 to £1,000 a month and mainly local customers? A freelancer or small team.
  3. You need video production, three or more platforms and ads? An agency.
  4. Social media drives most of your sales? Think about an in-house hire, maybe supported by a freelancer.

Whoever you choose, insist on these

  • You keep ownership of your accounts and content.
  • Access through Meta Business Suite, never your password. Here's how to do it.
  • A monthly plan you approve and a report with reach, clicks and messages, not just likes.
  • A clear notice period.

See more prices in how much social media management costs in the UK.

Questions people ask

Is it better to hire a social media freelancer or an agency?

For most small and local businesses, a freelancer or small team gives the best value. An agency makes sense when you need several platforms, video production and paid ads at the same time.

How much does a social media freelancer cost compared to an agency?

In the UK, freelancers usually charge £250 to £1,200 a month and small agencies £800 to £2,000. In the US, freelancers often charge $750 to $1,500 a month and small business agency programs $2,000 to $5,000.

Can I manage my business social media myself?

Yes, if you can post consistently. Pick one platform, aim for three good posts a week, batch your content and reply to comments.

When should I hire an in-house social media manager?

When social media is a main sales channel and there's a full-time job's worth of content, community and ads work. Until then, outsourcing is usually cheaper.

Want the personal service of a freelancer with a team behind it?

Cornelius and Mercy run social media for small businesses from £299 a month. Try 3 free sample posts first.